Friday, October 12th, 2012
I’ve just caught up with a very interesting Radio 4 documentary on “free schools”, which aired last night.
The piece prompted quite a few thoughts, but I was particularly taken by comments by, I think, Jeremy Rowe, the head of Sir John Leman school in Beccles, Suffolk, about the possible long-term impact of a new school – a “free school” – which opened in the town last month to make two secondaries there.
Mr Rowe’s concern was that although Beccles Free School has so far struggled for pupil numbers, in time it might take pupils away from Sir John Leman and that, in time, this might lead to serious disadvantages: specifically duplication of provision and, if I have remembered this correctly, the fact that Sir John Leman might no longer be able to operate, for example, courses in minority interest subjects.
This could lead to a situation where “there is less of the added value [his school currently provides] and you end up with two schools offering the same restricted diet”.
In other words, there were benefits to having pupils concentrated in one institution rather than split between two.
The counter-argument, put by supporters of free schools, is that competition between institutions, to use the standard and too-often-repeated cliché, forces each to “up their game”, or improve.
The to- and fro-of this is fairly routine in this debate. But what occurred to me is that the competition argument being used by free schools supporters seems to run directly counter to the argument used in much of the debate around healthcare.
There, a prevailing view – though often challenged, it has to be said, at a local level – is that sometimes hospitals need to close in order to focus specialist provision in single institutions. This is seen to be economically more efficient and also to promote the concept of centres of excellence. It also avoids duplication of services, I think the argument runs.
As I said, this argument seems to be well-balanced in the health sector, but the opposite of the prevailing view among current policy-makers in education.
If many people do, understandably, want to defend their local hospital from closure, I’m not aware of any argument that what we need to do, to improve health standards, is to open lots of new hospitals close to each other in order to force existing providers to “up their game”.
Someone might say I’m wrong there, and that this has been advocated.
But I guess the prevailing view would be that – to put it mildly – this would not be the best use of resources. You can argue,I guess, that schools are cheaper institutions than hospitals, but questions about the efficiency of the comparable project in the education sector will not go away, I feel.
The above represent just some very quick thoughts, but I would be fascinated to hear any responses.
I have always struggled with the competition v ;planned provision dichotomy because, to me, both positions have weaknesses. Monopoly provision (however owned and paid for) tends to exploitation, high price and low quality. Competition can make the provider more responsive to price and quality signals from users/consumers. However, it also produces oversupply (if supply = demand there is no competition), supplier failures and a diversion of resource (and quite a lot of it) into the apparatus of competition (e.g. spend on marketing, cost of transactions). So I have trouble reconciling the assertion that competition leads to greater efficiency with the obvious fact that, on the way, the services are more expensive!
We might not care about this when we are buying TVs, dry cleaning or holidays but we most surely do when the service is our children’s future or our health. Then, supplier failure has immediate and long term casualties.
The real-world solutions to these dilemmas are somewhere between market and centrally planned provision and how well these work and how fairly the benefits are distributed lies in the fine detail. I think what winds many of us up is the inconsistency (hypocrisy,maybe) of the positions adopted by politicians. Thus we get the promotion of more competition in the provision of schooling but, apparently, less of it in the provision of exams.
I think the major point of difference is that health outcomes depend heavily on the skill/resources of the doctors/hospital – what the patient thinks and feels is relatively unimportant. By contrast, how a child feels about their school is a hugely important factor in determining whether they will be a successful learner there. In a small school the relative importance of each pupil is greater, so two small schools could be better than one big if they each have a strong, positive ethos. But that’s a big ‘if’ and being small is no guarantee it will happen.
Actually, I’m not sure that the differences between health and education agency are that great. The evidence suggests that health is more co-constructed than is commonly believed (cf the powerful and REAL placebo effect).
What is certainly true is that teachers have failed to persuade the public and politicians that they have command of an arcane and opaque skill and knowledge set.which no-one else can understand. In reality there is less of this than meets the eye in doctoring and a lot more of it in education than popularly accepted
Having recently analysed all peer-reviewed journal papers comparing charter schools and public schools in the states between 2007 and the present, I couldn’t find a single paper that supported the view that competition between schools driven by new school openings delivers any increased student outcomes. There is evidence that it makes other principals think more about their competition and be more strategic in what they are doing, but the evidence that this converts to a better education for students (or higher achievement) is entirely missing.
One thing that is clearly demonstrated in several papers is that competition like this tends to increase segregation of ethnicity and classes. The view from the papers is that this increased segregation is not beneficial.
The hospital example has long seemed an important one. It strikes me that if hospitals were not working we wouldn’t decide to create NHS 2.0, but only in places were people decide they will sponsor hospitals, and then only for the x% who live in those areas. But I was led to believe (and am still open to the idea) that competition has improved many other sectors. The main concern now is that the evidence for it happening in education is not as ambiguous as I first thought. The absence of solid evidence that competition drives up standards is quite remarkable.
Interesting, thank you. From a practical point of view, centralisation of specialities in health tends to be for specialist functions only (cardiac units for example). It is done primarily to ensure better outcomes for patients (though not always perceived as such, for a number of reasons). And I agree, within healthcare itself there is a more mature debate on the expansion of specialist centres and its organisational implications.
For me one of the key differences between health and education is that commissioning is more overt in healthcare. Even before the reduction of role for LEAs, there was I think less awareness in the public at large of school capacity planning, and less knowledge about how education is funded. So in general, in health, we define a need and then seek to commission enough service to meet that need. Yes there is a choice of provider for many routine services (cataract surgery for instance), but that’s within an overall capacity plan; it’s not choice for the sake of it.
Free schools, by contrast, aim to provide choice in universal provision, and rarely enter specialist territory (I view the teaching of Latin as an extension of universal provision,not a specialism in itself!). There is, for me a fundamental flaw in using oversupply to increase choice and quality in education: the birthrate doesn’t rise in response to an increase in the number of school places. So the net result of opening free schools in areas where there are already enough school places is an increase in rhetoric and spin, and a significant increase in the cost of universal-level education due to duplication of places. If free schools were only used for properly specialist provision, the policy might look less wasteful and less divisive.
As parents, our interactions with education are frequent, much less so with healthcare. Following on from Ed’s point, I think it’s not just our children’s views which are important, it’s how influenced we are as parents by the national and local view of our schools, and of late the rhetoric is consistently negative about secondary education, with very few exceptions. So it’s not surprising, faced with a mountain of negativity about something which is a necessary part of our daily lives, and not knowing the costs involved, that some people fear existing provision won’t deliver, and seek out an alternative. But to address this, we need proper debate, not one-sided rhetoric.
I agree that there are parallels between education and healthcare provision and I am exploring this in my local area (SW London) as we move forward with Coalition reforms in these two highly political agendas. The big difference is that patients have little real say over their healthcare outcomes, whereas with a free school theoretically you can set one up as a group of parents and determine everything that goes on, assuming your Head has been recruited because he/she fully signs up to your vision. A bit like cloning really. Which of course is associated with sheep and the Nazis.
Kudos, I value this!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
online pharmacy no prescription
canadian online pharmacy
canada pharmacy online no script
canadian pharcharmy
Kudos, A good amount of advice.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian drug store mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canada pharmacies canada pharmacy
prescription prices comparison
canada pharmacy online
best price prescription drugs
cheap prescription drugs
canadian drug
buy cialis
Nicely put, With thanks!
https://nicktambone.com/
discount prescription drug canada drug online pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies-24h
mexican online pharmacies
get prescription online
canada pharmacies
international pharmacy
compare rx prices
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
Kudos! Quite a lot of knowledge!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
prescription drugs online without doctor canada drugs the canadian pharmacy global pharmacy canada
cheap prescription drugs
mexican pharmacy online medications
online discount pharmacy
highest rated canadian pharmacies
best canadian prescription prices
canadian drugs
Good data. Kudos!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
pharmacy cost comparison canadian pharmacies that ship to us canadapharmacyonline.com canadian pharmacy online
canadian rx
legitimate online pharmacies
canadian pharmacies top best
no prescription online pharmacy
pharmacy online store
prescription drugs without prior prescription
Thanks, A good amount of advice!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
buy drugs online canadian pharmacies best online pharmacies no prescription canada drugs online
canada pharmacies
canadian drugstore reviews
rx online
rx price comparison
mexican online pharmacies
no prescription pharmacies
Terrific advice. Kudos.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
prescription cost canadian pharmacies northwest pharmacy online pharmacies canada
canadian family pharmacy
canadian pharmacy online canada
canada online pharmacies
canadian drugstore online
online pharmacy usa
canadian family pharmacy
Thank you. Ample content!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
internet pharmacy canadianpharmacy canada pharmacies prescription drugs canadian pharmaceuticals online
rx online
cheap prescription drugs online
pharmacy online
buying prescription drugs canada
mexican online pharmacies
canadian drug
You revealed this fantastically!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canada pharmacy online no script canadian drugs canadian family pharmacy canada drug
online pharmacy reviews
discount prescription drug
canadian drug
canadian pharmacy online
overseas pharmacies
pharmacy canada
You mentioned this really well!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada drugs online canadian pharmacies that ship to us prescription prices comparison online pharmacies canada
prescription cost
highest rated canadian pharmacies
pharmacy cost comparison
mail order pharmacies
us pharmacy no prior prescription
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
Beneficial info. Regards!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadapharmacy com london drugs canada canada drugs canada drugs online
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican pharmacies online
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacies without script
pharmacy near me
canadian prescription drugs
Fantastic forum posts, Many thanks!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian pharmacies top best canadian pharmaceuticals online canada drugs online pharmacy canadian pharmacies without an rx
canadadrugs
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacy no prescription
pharmacy price comparison
canadian drug stores online
prescription drugs online without
Truly a lot of good material.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian pharmacy king canadian pharcharmy get prescription online canadian viagra
cheap prescription drugs
pharmacy drug store
canada drugs pharmacy
medication costs
legitimate online pharmacies
canadian pharcharmy online
Kudos. Plenty of data!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
pharmacy canada mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canadian mail order pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online
legitimate online pharmacies
medical information online
online pharmacy no prescription needed
pharmacies in canada
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canadian drug store
Excellent posts. Thanks a lot.
https://nicktambone.com/
rx price comparison trust pharmacy canada canadian prescriptions canada drugs online
pharmacies in canada
canadian prescriptions
mail order pharmacy
no prior prescription required pharmacy
online canadian pharmacy
canadian rx pharmacy online
Nicely put, Cheers.
http://talahicc.com/
prescription cost canadian pharcharmy prescription drugs without prior prescription canadian pharmacies
best canadian prescription prices
canadapharmacy com
walmart pharmacy price check
international pharmacy
cialis canadian pharmacy
discount pharmacy online
Nicely put, Many thanks!
http://talahicc.com/
walgreens pharmacy northwestpharmacy canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs top rated canadian pharmacies online
canada pharmacies
the canadian pharmacy
prescription cost comparison
northwestpharmacy
pharmacy price compare
canadian discount pharmacy
You’ve made your point!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
cialis canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy online canadianpharmacy canadian viagra
canadian online pharmacies
candrugstore com
canadian pharmacies top best
canadian pharmacy reviews
canadadrugs
prescription drug
Terrific write ups. Many thanks.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
get prescription online north west pharmacy canada internet pharmacy canadianpharmacy
pharmacies near me
prescription drug
costco pharmacy pricing
canadian pharmacy viagra
drugstore online
online pharmacies no prescription
You actually expressed it really well.
https://nicktambone.com/
best online canadian pharcharmy canada pharmacy buy prescription drugs from canada canadian pharmacies-24h
canadian pharmacies that are legit
online drugstore
prescription cost
pharmacy near me
online pharmacy no prescription
price prescription drugs
Cheers. An abundance of stuff.
https://nicktambone.com/
approved canadian pharmacies online canadian pharcharmy online pharmacy usa canadian pharcharmy
canadianpharmacy
canada drug prices
online canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
prescription online
canada meds
Useful content. Thanks.
https://nicktambone.com/
pharmacy online mexico northwestpharmacy prescription drugs online without doctor canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy online orders
online rx pharmacy
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
online pharmacy without a prescription
canada online pharmacy
online drugs
Really lots of very good facts.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
pharmacy tech online pharmacies canada canadian pharmacy no prescription canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmacies that are legit
canadian pharmacies top best
candrugstore com
canadian pharmacy no prescription
canadian pharmacy king
prescription drugs online without doctor
You have made your point!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
24 hour pharmacy mexican pharmacies shipping to usa pharmacy price compare canadian pharmacies without an rx
overseas pharmacies
pharmacy prices compare
discount prescription drug
discount prescription drugs online
pharmacy tech
canadian drugstore reviews
Incredible loads of valuable material.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
pharmacy online canadian pharmacies-24h canadian pharmacy no prescription needed canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacies
canadapharmacy
canada pharmacy no prescription
24 hour pharmacy
canadian pharmacies that are legit
drugs from canada
You actually suggested this effectively.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
my canadian pharmacy global pharmacy canada meds online online pharmacies of canada
best canadian mail order pharmacies
mexican pharmacy online medications
canadian drugs without prescription
highest rated canadian pharmacies
pharmacy online mexico
canadian rx pharmacy online
Nicely put, Many thanks!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian rx pharmacy online north west pharmacy canada the canadian pharmacy canadian drugs
canadian prescription drugstore
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
drug stores near me
online prescription drugs
best non prescription online pharmacies
drugs without prescription
You actually expressed it really well.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian drugstore reviews canada drug canada pharmacies canadian pharmacies
pharmacies in canada
canadian pharcharmy online
most reliable canadian pharmacies
mail order pharmacy
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
Amazing tons of beneficial material!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
pharmacies in canada canadian pharmacies that ship to us pharmacy tech mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
medical information online
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
canadian pharma companies
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
trust pharmacy canada
best online pharmacies canada
Cheers. Great information!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian drugs global pharmacy canada online canadian discount pharmacy canadian online pharmacy
no prescription online pharmacy
online drugstore
highest rated canadian pharmacies
canadian prescription
pharmacy drug store
<a href="http://vincent.bonduau.free.fr/?s=+Good+knowledge.+Kudos.+http%3A%2F%2Fcanadianpharmacyntx.com%2F+reputable+canadian+mail+order+pharmacies+canada+pharmaceutical+online+ordering+pharmacy+cost+comparison+canadian+cialis+%0D%0Acanada+pharmacy+online+reviews+%0D%0Adiscount+drugs+online+pharmacy+%0D%0Acanadapharmacyonline+com+%0D%0Ano+prescription+pharmacy+%0D%0Aonline+canadian+pharcharmy+%0D%0Apharmacy+price+compare”>pharmacies near me
You actually expressed this adequately!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
pharmacies in canada aarp approved canadian online pharmacies pharmacy price comparison canada online pharmacies
trusted overseas pharmacies
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
pharmacy drug store
canadian rx pharmacy online
my canadian pharmacy
mexican pharmacies
Really a lot of very good info.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
top rated canadian pharmacies online canada pharmaceutical online ordering canadapharmacyonline.com canadian drugs
cheap canadian drugs
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
canada pharmacy no prescription
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian discount pharmacy
prescription drug price comparison
Thank you, Valuable information!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions canadian pharcharmy 24 hour pharmacy mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican pharmacy online
buy cialis
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
top rated online canadian pharmacies
rx pharmacy
prescription drugs online without doctor
You definitely made your point.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian drugstore reviews canadian pharmaceuticals online canadian viagra northwestpharmacy
ed meds online
cheap drugs online
pharmacy prices compare
canadian prescription drugstore
canadian pharma companies
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
Wonderful info. Thank you.
https://nicktambone.com/
buy prescription drugs online canadian pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online canada pharmaceuticals online
cialis online
canada pharmacies without script
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian prescriptions
drug price
canadian pharmacies that are legit
You have made the point.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian mail order pharmacies canada pharmacy online online pharmacy reviews canadian viagra
prescription drug assistance
prescription drugs canada
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican pharmacies online
canada pharmacies without script
canadian pharmacy online canada
You’ve made the point!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacy without prescription canada drug buy prescription drugs from canada canada online pharmacies
prescription drugs online without doctor
ed meds online
the canadian pharmacy
drug price
drugs for sale
canadian pharmacies
Many thanks! Helpful stuff!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
mail order pharmacies canadian cialis prescription drug cost canada pharmaceutical online ordering
pharmacy online mexico
discount pharmacy
buying drugs canada
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
prescription drug cost
drugs online
Thank you, A good amount of material.
http://talahicc.com/
prescription drugs canada canada pharmaceuticals online mexican pharmacy online medications trust pharmacy canada
pharmacies in canada
canada pharmacy online reviews
online drugs
web medical information
canadian drugstore
best non prescription online pharmacies
You actually revealed this really well!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada pharmacies without script canadian online pharmacy overseas pharmacy forum canadian pharmaceuticals online
canadapharmacyonline com
best non prescription online pharmacies
northwest pharmacy canada
prescription drug
drugstore online
online pharmacy without a prescription
Amazing content. Cheers!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
discount pharmaceuticals canadian viagra pharmacy without dr prescriptions canadian pharmacies-24h
candrugstore com
prescription drugs without prior prescription
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
pharmacy online mexico
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
discount pharmaceuticals
Nicely put. Regards.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian drug stores online global pharmacy canada canadian pharmacy viagra brand canadian pharmacy online
canada drugs online
best online pharmacies no prescription
prescription cost
canadian family pharmacy
canadian drug
drugs for sale
Good forum posts. Thanks.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
compare prescription prices canadian pharmacies online international pharmacy canadian pharmacies that ship to us
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
best non prescription online pharmacies
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
online rx pharmacy
drug prices comparison
canada pharmacy online reviews
Thank you. Loads of info.
https://nicktambone.com/
best non prescription online pharmacies canadian drugs pharmacy prescription canadian pharmacy online
no prescription pharmacies
prescription drug
canadian drug
canadian online pharmacy reviews
canada online pharmacy
prescription prices comparison
Thanks. Plenty of advice!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
pharmacy near me canada pharmacy canadian prescriptions canadian pharmacies-24h
canadian pharmacies top best
online pharmacy no prescription needed
pharmacy near me
meds online
prescription drugs without prior prescription
no prior prescription required pharmacy
Amazing lots of awesome data.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada pharmacies canada pharmaceuticals online canadadrugs canada drugs
canadian drugs
online drugstore
canadian pharmacy 365
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
prescription drugs without prior prescription
cheap drugs online
You stated that very well!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
online canadian pharmacies online pharmacies canada canadian pharmacy uk delivery canadian pharmacies without an rx
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canadian pharmacy 365
rx pharmacy
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
online canadian pharcharmy
canadian family pharmacy
Thanks. Fantastic information!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada drugs online canada pharmacy online prescription drugs canada pharmacy online
canadian mail order pharmacies
web medical information
prescription drugs prices
candrugstore com
drugs without prescription
online drugs
This is nicely expressed. !
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
best online international pharmacies online pharmacies canada canadian rx north west pharmacy canada
pharmacy prices compare
online pharmacy reviews
best canadian online pharmacy
pharmacies in canada
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
mexican online pharmacies
Really all kinds of helpful knowledge.
https://nicktambone.com/
prescription pricing canada online pharmacies prescription online north west pharmacy canada
canada pharmacy online reviews
canadian online pharmacies
price prescription drugs
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
us pharmacy no prior prescription
pharmacy near me
You said it adequately..
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
pharmacy cost comparison canada drugs discount pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online
pharmacy cost comparison
online pharmacies no prescription
canada online pharmacy
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian pharmacies top best
Helpful data. Regards!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
prescription drugs canada aarp approved canadian online pharmacies drug prices comparison canadian pharmacies that ship to us
best online international pharmacies
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacy meds
pharmacies near me
canadian pharmacy online
buy cialis
Awesome stuff, Regards.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions canadian pharmacies that ship to us canadian online pharmacy top rated canadian pharmacies online
canadian pharmacy king
mexican pharmacy online medications
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
buy cialis
online pharmacy no prescription
canada drug prices
Very well voiced truly. !
http://talahicc.com/
canadian cialis global pharmacy canada canada pharmacy online canadian pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy reviews
prescription drug price comparison
canada online pharmacies
international pharmacy
canadian pharmacies top best
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian discount pharmacy online pharmacies canada canadian online pharmacies online pharmacies canada
buy prescription drugs without doctor
prescription drug price comparison
canada pharmacy online orders
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
pain meds online without doctor prescription
canada drug
Many thanks! Numerous advice!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
prescription cost comparison canadian pharmacies-24h canadian pharmacy reviews canadian cialis
online pharmacy no prescription
discount pharmacy online
discount pharmaceuticals
drug prices comparison
prescription drugs online without doctor
best canadian mail order pharmacies
Wow a good deal of amazing facts.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
candrugstore com canadian pharmacies-24h canadian pharmacy king canada online pharmacies
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
meds online
pharmacy near me
international pharmacy
canadian pharmacy 365
You said it very well.!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canada drugs online global pharmacy canada online rx pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
mexican pharmacies
canadian pharmacies that are legit
canada pharmacy
cialis online
buy drugs online
no prescription pharmacy